BUTLER HILL CEMETERY
DEERFIELD TOWNSHIP TIOGA COUNTY, PA. Deerfield Township
The following list is part of the Tioga County Cemetery Inscriptions– Volume 3. Copied by Rhoda ENGLISH Ladd and Lola WETHERBEE Franke August 2, 1972. Reprinted with permsission of Rhoda ENGLISH Ladd.
The second largest cemetery in Deerfield is incorporated as the Highland Cemetery Association and the cemetery is known as the Butler Hill Cemetery. It is located opposite the Baptist Church on Butler Hill. Wanting to have a burial ground in East Chatham, as this area was called, a meeting was held Sept. 14, 1869 at the home of Rev. Selden Butler for the purpose of making arrangements for the purchase of a lot from Elihu Bowen and Selden Butler. It is located on Road 58028.
| Butler Hill Cemetery 2010 | Butler Hill Cemetery Obituaries |
| Sutton | Richard | 1855 | 1924 | Father | ||
| Sutton | Lola May | July 6, 1863 | Dec. 24, 1901 | Mother | ||
| Thompson | Hulda | Mar. 28 1886 | age 1 y, 6m. | "Little Hulda" d/of L.& J. Thompson. | ||
| Sutton | Isaac | Mar. 9, 1824 | Feb. 13, 1906 | |||
| Sutton | Hulda | Oct 10, 1821 | Nov. 20, 1890 | w/of Isaac | ||
| Kemp | Betsey A. | 1860 | 1946 | |||
| VanDusen | Herbert | 1864 | 1916 | |||
| VanDusen | Adell | 1865 | 1941 | w/of Herbert | ||
| VanDusen | D.L. | May 26, 1833 | July 24, 1901 | Civ. War marker & flag | ||
| VanDusen | Julia | 1841 | 1921 | w/of D.L. | ||
| VanDusen | Bennie | Feb. 17, 1872 | Atr. 4, 1881 | s/of D.L. & Julia M. | ||
| VanDusen | Eva | Mar. 16, 1863 | Mar. 18, 1881 | d/of D.L. & Julia | ||
| Daniels | Ben. B. | 1881 | 1959 | |||
| Daniels | Blanche S. | 1883 | 1947 | |||
| Daniels | Melissa | 1839 | 1899 | |||
| Daniels | Henry F. | 1817 | 1899 | Father | ||
| Daniels | Esther G. | 1816 | 1900 | Mother | ||
| Daniels | H.F. | 1817 | 1899 | Civ. War Flag & marker | ||
| Daniels | Jerusha Lee | 1845 | 1912 | w/of H.F. | ||
| Daniels | Ned J. | 1867 | 1941 | |||
| Daniels | Fred F. | 1867 | 1889 | |||
| Daniels | George H. | 1886 | 1969 | |||
| Day | Abram | May 22, 1825 | Jan. 8, 1899 | |||
| Day | Mary J. | Aug. 19, 1835 | No Date | w/of Abram | ||
| Day | Martha J. | June 19, 1834 | Jan. 14, 1899 | w/of T.Z. | ||
| Day | Bennie O. | July 3, 1882 | July 21, 1884 | (see below - on a separate stone) | ||
| Day | Bennie O. | July 3, 1882 | July 21, 1884 | s/of Z.T. & M.J. - appears on the same as the T.Z. | ||
| Day | Fred G. | 1884 | 1952 | |||
| Wells | Anita Marie | 1913 | 1964 | In memory by Ben Greene | ||
| Carl | William A. | 1884 | 1948 | |||
| Carl | Laura A. | 1889 | 19** | ** Uncut | ||
| Finnerty | Richard F. | 1942 | 1965 | Served armed forces from 1941-1945 | ||
| Westmiller | W.H. | 1855 | 1958 | |||
| Westmiller|d> | Margaret | 1866 | 1942 | |||
| Westmiller | Guy | 1887 | 1958 | |||
| Westmiller | Mary | 1888 | 1968 | |||
| * | *Unmarked Grave here | |||||
| Stanley | Harry M. | 1890 | 1950 | |||
| Stanley | Sylvester H. | 1860 | 1935 | |||
| Stanley | Eliza T. | 1864 | 1935 | |||
| Stanley | Hubert Lee | 1894 | 1971 | |||
| Brown | Merle F. | 1903 | 19** | (** uncut??) | ||
| Brown | Lena S. | 1900 | 1966 | |||
| Carl | Edgar | 1866 | 1937 | Father | ||
| Carl | Lolie | 1866 | 1918 | Mother | ||
| Carl | Emmet W. | 1889 | 1968 | |||
| Carl | Charlotte E. | 1896 | 19** | (** uncut??) | ||
| Carl | Everett | 1926 | 1944 | s/of E.W. & C.E. | ||
| Brown | Richard Gene | Jan. 25, 1938 | Jan. 28, 1938 | s/of Eldon & Rita | ||
| Seely | Henry Morris | Aug. 22, 1836 | Mar. 28, 1911 | Father | ||
| Seely | Emily E. | Apr. 24, 1831 | 6/1/03 | Mother w/of Henry | ||
| Seely | George B. | July 4, 1870 | Apr. 16, 1907 | s/of H.M & E.E. | ||
| Seely | Mary B. | July 26, 1872 | aged 12-3-1 | d/of H.M & E.E. | ||
| Seely | J.D. | 1864 | 1917 | |||
| Seely - Lg. Stone no graves | ||||||
| Wheaton | Silas B. | Feb. 28, 1849 | 5/18/11 | Father | ||
| Butler | Laura **Wheaton | 1859 | 1941 | Mother *NOTE: Laura's nee is ALLEN- m.1st. Wheaton 2nd. Butler - Ref. Judy Allen Cwiklinski | ||
| Wheaton | Ellen | 1851 | 1888 | d/of J.M. & Sylvia | ||
| Wheaton | Luther | Oct. 15, 1847 | May 27, 1870 | Co.F, 4th Reg. Maine Vol. Civ War flag | ||
| Wheaton | John M. | Mar. 30, 1824 | Feb. 26, 1901 | Father | ||
| Wheaton | Sylvia | Nov. 5, 1824 | Sept. 11, 1897 | Mother | ||
| Barr | Mina | Feb. 19, 1857 | Nov. 13, 1897 | Mother -- w/of Nathan | ||
| Barr | Nathan | 1851 | 19** | ** un-cut | ||
| Barr | Ellen | 1855 | 19** | ** un-cut | ||
| Flat stone on ground----Unreadable | ||||||
| Chamberlain | Etta | June 29, 1867 | Mar. 31, 1897 | w/of G.W. | ||
| Satterly | Samuel D. | 1838 | 1911 | Co. E. 42 Reg. Pa. Vol. Flag | ||
| Satterly | Delilah | 1838 | 1911 | w/S.D. dates-sic - JKC - as written | ||
| Taylor | Winslow | 1812 | 1885 | Father | ||
| Taylor | Margaret | 1832 | 1914 | w/of Winslow | ||
| Taylor | May. | June 10, 1869 | Oct. 16, 1849 | d/of Mr & Mrs. Winslow Taylor | ||
| Dewey | Hiram | 1848 | 1918 | Father | ||
| Dewey | Ida | 1858 | 1918 | Mother | ||
| Dimmick | Walter S. | June 4, 1870 | May. 3, 1944 | |||
| Dimmick | Maggie A. | Mar. 3, 1879 | Aug. 29, 1953 | |||
| "RICE on front of Family Stone | ||||||
| SEELY on back, with individual stones" | the below indiv. | |||||
| *Ernest D. | 1882 | 1953 | ||||
| *Phebe A. | 1880 | 1937 | ||||
| *Grace | 1904 | **** | **** Uncut | |||
| Smith | *Ethel G. Rice | 1908 | **** | **** Uncut | ||
| Seely | James H. | 1844 | 1919 | Co. H., 207th Pa., Vol. Civ. War | ||
| Seely | Annah E. | 1849 | 1932 | w/of James H. | ||
| Mack | Minnie B. | 1871 | 1918 | |||
| Odle | Hattie | Apr. 27, 1858 | June 22, 1899 | w/of A.S. | ||
| Odle | Hattie | Stone - no dates | ||||
| Odle | Gerald | Stone - no dates | ||||
| Odle | Fred | Stone - no dates | ||||
| Odle | Eula | Dec. 22, 1888 | Mar. 11, 1912 | d/of A.S. & H.E. | ||
| Bosard | Ann E. | Apr. 5, 1837 | July 17, 1882 | |||
| ** | Graves here no markers | |||||
| Seamans | Israel | Feb. 20, 1826 | 7/13/08 | Father | ||
| Seamans | Emma Jane | Jan. 5, 1834 | Dec. 31, 1900 | w/of Israel | ||
| Seamans | George B. | 1858 | 1923 | |||
| Seamans | Ida F. | 1863 | 1934 | w/of George B. | ||
| Seamans | Clair E. | 1915 | 1965 | |||
| Seamans | June L. | 1916 | 19** | ** uncut?? | ||
| ** | ** Footstone - E.W. | |||||
| Kizer | Adelia | July 12, 1856 | June 29, 1899 | w/of S.D. Kizer | ||
| Kizer | Seldon D. | 1853 | 1936 | |||
| Kizer | Mortimer J. | 1892 | 1919 | |||
| ** | ** more graves on Kizer plot but no markers. | |||||
| Bowen | Elihu | Mar. 14, 1819 | Feb. 14, 1896 | |||
| Bowen | Eliza A. | Sept. 15, 1824 | Nov. 5, 1897 | |||
| Bowen | Lena | July 26, 1859 | Sept. 5, 1881 | d/of Elihu & Eliza | ||
| Wheaton | Elmer H. | 1851 | 1923 | Father | ||
| Wheaton | Eva J. | 1854 | 1887 | w/of E.H. | ||
| Wheaton | Raymond | Jan. 31, 1880 | Jan. 9, 1902 | s/of E.H. & E.J. | ||
| Wheaton | Alma | Nov. 7, 1884 | Apr. 4, 1902 | d/of E.H. & E.J. | ||
| Weeks | Alma | May 23, 1813 | Mar. 11, 1890 | |||
| Doan | Floyd W. | 1874 | 1914 | Lodge emblem & #324 -Brotherhood of Railroad Trainmen. Lg. Family Stone. | ||
| Stafford | Fred W. | 1896 | 1969 | |||
| Stafford | Hazel C. | 1894 | 19** | ** - uncut??? | ||
| Carl | E. Wayne | 1914 | 19** | ** - uncut??? | ||
| Carl | Winifred S. | 1915 | 19** | ** - uncut??? | ||
| Edwards | Leo H. | 1884 | 1946 | Edwards family all on a Lg. stone tog. | ||
| Edwards | Stella C. | 1887 | 1955 | |||
| Edwards | Basil | 5/23/09 | Aug. 18, 1909 | s/of L.H. & E | ||
| Edwards | Gertie | 1875 | 1908 | s/of H.G. & Mary | ||
| ** | **Several Graves - No markers | |||||
| Bloom | William | Jan. 62, 1839 | Oct. 31, 1904 | Father -- Co. D. 136th P.U. | ||
| Bloom | Sarah M. | Aug. 1, 1842 | Dec. 14, 1908 | w/of William | ||
| Brown | Alfred E. | 1876 | 19** | ** Uncut??? | ||
| Brown | Anna S. | 1879 | 1947 | |||
| Campbell | R.W. | Aug. 20, 1830 | * | *No date - Co. H. 207 Pa. Vol. Civ War | ||
| Campbell | Jane L. | May 9, 1849 | Nov. 19, 1911 | w/of R.W. | ||
| Kizer | Nicholas | * | * | *No dates - Co. A. 149 Pa. Inf. Civ War | ||
| ** | **Footstone for J. K. | |||||
| Kizer | Henry | 1843 | 1919 | Father - Co. H. Pa. Vol. Civ. War | ||
| Kizer | Lucy J. | Aug. 23, 1848 | Feb. 11, 1904 | |||
| Kizer | Fved | 1869 | 1926 | Brother | ||
| Kizer | Ned J. | 1877 | 1943 | M.W.A. Emblem & Axe | ||
| Kizer | Martha E. | 1881 | 1941 | |||
| Kizer | W.W. | Oct. 15, 1844 | Aug. 26, 1902 | Father | ||
| Grover | Jane | Oct. 4, 1845 | ** | ** uncut w/of W.W. | ||
| Odle | Abram | Nov. 19, 1873 | Feb. 2, 1904 | |||
| Odle | Lucretia B. | 1871 | 1956 | w/of Abram | ||
| Odle | Herbert F. | 1879 | 1944 | |||
| Odle | DeFrance | 1854 | 1900 | Father | ||
| Odle | Ella E. | 1854 | 1919 | Mother | ||
| Odle | Dora M. | 1881 | 1965 | |||
| Upham | Viola | July 4, 1853 | Dec. 7, 1889 | w/of William- also a footstone w/ V.U. | ||
| Baird | Enora | June 15, 1874 | Apr. 30, 1901 | w/of W.A. Baird | ||
| Baird | Elwin | 5/5/01 | Age 8mo-28d | s/of W.A. & E. Baird | ||
| Baird | William A. | 1868 | 1937 | |||
| Baird | Francis | 1866 | 1924 | w/of W.A. Baird | ||
| Croft | M.A. | Feb. 26, 1841 | Dec. 27, 1891 | Co. A. 149 Pa. Vol. Civ. War | ||
| Croft | Gertrude | Oct. 4, 1857 | Dec. 25, 1889 | w/of M.A. | ||
| Croft | John S. | June 8, 1847 | Aug. 30, 1908 | Father | ||
| Croft | Maria C. | May 19, 1861 | 6/17/45 | Mother | ||
| Odle | Minnie | May 2, 1856 | Feb. 3, 1884 | |||
| Foley | Allen D. | 1900 | * | Uncut | ||
| Foley | Ruth R. | 1903 | * | Uncut | ||
| Sears | Theodore | 1882 | 1884 | child of Jas. D. & Mary V. Sears | ||
| Sears | Edith May | 1885 | 1885 | child of Jas. D. & Mary V. Sears | ||
| Sears | Ida M. | 1893 | 1894 | child of Jas. D. & Mary V. Sears | ||
| Kizer | James | June 18, 1881 | 66 yr & 7 mo | Co. L. 2nd Pa. Cav. | ||
| Kizer | Martha M. | Sept. 15, 1891 | aged 70 | w/of James | ||
| Kizer | Joel | 1846 | 1924 | Co. L. 2nd. Pa. Cav. | ||
| Kizer | Caroline | 1848 | 1924 | w/of Joel | ||
| Horton | Floyd L. | 1879 | 1939 | |||
| Horton | Nellie K. | 1873 | 1956 | |||
| Gardner | Almon T. | Dec. 18, 18** | age 32 | **Stone broken - year of death unknown | ||
| Yentzer | Marion | 1901 | 1967 | Kenyon Funeral Home marker. | ||
| Seely | Charles | 1843 | 1915 | |||
| Seely | Kattie | 1877 | 1884 | d/of Chas. & Sarah | ||
| Johnson | O.J. | Sept. 9, 1835 | * | *Uncut? - 207 Co. H. Pa. Vol. | ||
| Johnson | Melissa | June 30, 1835 | Oct. 26, 1890 | w/of O.J. | ||
| Johnson | Clara | Sept. 10, 1868 | Apr. 3, 1892 | d/of O.G. & M.J. | ||
| Johnson | Orange | 1842 | 1923 | Father - 207 Pa. Vol. Civ. War | ||
| Curran | Lias M. | Feb. 4, 1877 | 45-6-15 | |||
| * | * - Stone with Curran broke -- wife? | |||||
| Teachman | Frank C. | 1858 | 1899 | |||
| Teachman | Frances C. | 1861 | 1947 | |||
| Harrington | Frank | 1873 | 1947 | |||
| Cole | Jesse | 1880 | 1954 | |||
| Cole | Lurie | *1844 | 1944 | *Should y.o.b be 1884? -- sic. | ||
| Cole | John | Apr. 6, 1887 | Dec. 25, 1955 | PA. Cook - 31 Field Art. WW I | ||
| Seely | Frank | Apr. 15, 1854 | Age 4mo & 3d | s/of J.B. & H. | ||
| Seely | Eddy | Dec. 20, 1856 | Aged 3 mo. | s/of Jonas B. & Hannah | ||
| Seely | Jonas B. | Mar. 17, 1810 | Dec. 29, 1888 | |||
| Seely | Hannah | Nov. 25, 1815 | May 29, 1898 | |||
| Tyler | Harry | Apr. 20, 1840 | Jan. 26, 1899 | |||
| Tyler | Romyette Olds | Dec. 5, 1841 | Oct. 1, 1906 | Nee: Olds | ||
| Tyler | Erwin | May 24, 1873 | 3-3-12 | ch of Harry Jr. & Romyette Tyler | ||
| Tyler | Oscar | May 6, 1873 | 4-6-4 | ch of Harry Jr. & Romyette Tyler | ||
| Stanley | Homer D. | 1892 | 1894 | s/of Sylvester & Eliza | ||
| Gates | Adaline O. | Apr. 4, 1888 | 53-1-12 | |||
| Gates | Letty | * | 3yrs & 14 days | * No date entered - "Our little Letty" | ||
| Gates | Merton L. | 1871 | 1928 | |||
| Roberts | Lena Gates | 1884 | 1967 | Nee: Gates | ||
| Smith | Carrie | 1891 | 19** | ** Uncut? | ||
| Church | Daniel | Aug. 9, 1874 | 64-11-12 | |||
| Church | Hannah | Aug. 9, 1811 | June 11, 1885 | |||
| Church | Daniel | Apr. 8, 1864 | 24 & 11 mo. | "Died while in defense of his country." s/of Daniel & Hannah | ||
| Church | Theophilus | May 16, 1862 | 30 & 29 days | |||
| Church | Addilaide | 1844 | 1928 | |||
| Church | Newbury | 1847 | 1925 | |||
| Church | Theodore | 1831 | 1915 | |||
| Church | Ester J. | 1833 | 1898 | w/of T. Church | ||
| Clark | Mary | Jan. 13, 1872 | June 10, 1894 | |||
| Church | Francis M. | Mar. 13, 1882 | 43-3-14 | G.A.R. Civ. War holder - but no service record | ||
| Church | F. Lee | 1880 | 1954 | |||
| Miles | Mary | July 24, 1869 | Feb. 19, 1895 | w/of C.M. Miles | ||
| Doan | Willard C. | 1897 | 19** | ** uncut? | ||
| Doan | Marjorie R. | 1898 | 19** | ** uncut? | ||
| Cooney | J. Arthur | 1905 | 1934 | |||
| Doan | Bert L. | 1882 | 1959 | |||
| Doan | Myrtle A. | 1885 | 1954 | w/of Bert | ||
| Doan | Charles H. | 1879 | 1946 | |||
| Doan | Maude E. | 1883 | 1962 | w/of Charles | ||
| Doan | Jacob B. | 1807 | 1882 | |||
| Doan | Sally Ann | 1812 | 1898 | w/of Jacob | ||
| Doan | Sylvester C. | 1840 | 1923 | |||
| Doan | Polly B. | 1842 | 1914 | w/of Sylvester | ||
| Kizer | C.R. | 1863 | 1916 | Father | ||
| Kizer | Alice | 1866 | 1933 | Mother | ||
| Kizer | Anna | Dec. 8, 1891 | Oct. 24, 1899 | d/of C. & A. | ||
| Clemens | Harold A. | 1899 | 1961 | |||
| Clemens | Grace M. | 1896 | ** | ** uncut | ||
| Baird | Nathan | May 3, 1836 | Oct. 20, 1909 | |||
| Baird | Catherine | Apr. 13, 1835 | Apr. 24, 1871 | w/of Nathan | ||
| Baird | Eliza E. | May 19, 1843 | Nov. 13, 1910 | w/of Nathan | ||
| Owlett | Fannie M. | Feb. 21, 1861 | May 14, 1881 | |||
| Stratton | Nettie J. Baird | May 9, 1873 | Nov. 21, 1911 | Nee: Baird | ||
| Butler | M.S. | Dec. 30, 1839 | Aug. 2, 1898 | Father | ||
| Butler | Jane | July 2, 1841 | Mar. 27, 1903 | Mother | ||
| Butler | Jud A. | 1870 | 1953 | |||
| Butler | Alice T. | 1872 | 1942 | |||
| Butler | * | Jan. 29, 1913 | *Infant dau. of J.A. & Alice Butler | |||
| Butler | Ralph E. | 1902 | 1926 | |||
| Butler | Merlin R. | 1916 | 1940 | |||
| Ladd | Laurence E. | 1900 | 1971 | W.W.1 - marker & flag | ||
| Butler | Esther B. | 1919 | * | * Uncut? | ||
| Ladd | Sharon K. | 1947 | *(is she the dau of L. & E. ?) | |||
| Churchill | Lena May | Mar 10, 1882 | Apr. 10, 1882 | d/of C.B. & E. | ||
| Butler | Larry D. | June 18, 1932 | Jul. 4, 1932 | |||
| Butler | Esther Dawn | Jan. 13, 1937 | Sept. 19, 1938 | |||
| Wetmore | May. | * | * | *No dates --- " Baby May d/of B. & L." | ||
| Butler | Waldo S. | 1894 | 19** | ** Uncut? | ||
| Butler | Mabel Treat | 1894 | 1922 | Nee: Treat -- w/of W.S. | ||
| Butler | Florence A. | 1925 | * | * Uncut? | ||
| Sutton | Emma M. | Sept. 21, 1850 | Nov. 19, 1896 | w/of E.D. Sutton | ||
| Butler | Elantson | 1851 | 1925 | |||
| Butler | Franklin | 1854 | 1947 | |||
| Butler | Polly | 1855 | 1938 | w/of Franklin | ||
| Butler | John N. | 1870 | 1892 | |||
| Butler | Norris | 1839 | 1913 | |||
| Ream | Betsey Ann | *1846 | 1922 | *(says Ream, but insinuates that she is the wife of Norris Butler)put in as written. | ||
| Ream | Nellie L. | *1865 | 1935 | *insinuates that she is a Butler - sic. | ||
| Butler | Seldon | July 15, 1806 | Oct. 19, 1888 | Father | ||
| Butler | Lucretia | May 30, 1813 | Jan. 11, 1886 | Mother w/of Selden | ||
| Butler | Salem J. | 1848 | 1927 | |||
| Butler | Mary E. | 1851 | 1918 | w/of Salem | ||
| Butler | Milton J. | 1873 | 1892 | s/of Salem & Mary | ||
| Butler | Milton S. | May 19, 1867 | aged 29-2-11 | ** Believe this & the next to be the one and the same. | ||
| Butler | S.M. | Mar. 8, 1838 | May 19, 1867 | |||
| Doan | Herman E. | 1878 | 1943 | |||
| Doan | Frances W. | 1881 | 1943 | |||
| Kizer | Abijah | May 29, 1837 | Oct. 6, 1901 | Co. H. 207th Pa Vol. - Flag & marker | ||
| ** | ** Note say's that the following the typist left out- should be between DeFrance Odle & Bertl L. Doan. | |||||
| Butler | Allen | 1798 | 1868 | |||
| Butler | Dimmis H. | 1809 | 1887 | w/Allen Butler | ||
| Butler | Aaron A. | 1838 | 1916 | |||
| Butler | Caroline L. | 1849 | 1917 | w/Aaron A. | ||
| Butler | Freddie | Oct. 13, 1870 | Oct. 2, 1881 | s/of A.A. & C.L. | ||
| Farnsworth | Willie A. | 1871 | 1943 | Father | ||
| Farnsworth | Flora E. | 1879 | 19** | Mother | ||
| Farnsworth | * | Nov. 3, 1908 | * Infant son of W.A. & F.E. Farnsworth | |||
| Butler | Coral M. | 1876 | 1940 | |||
| Butler | Martha E. | 1878 | 19** | ** Uncut? | ||
| Odle | Blanche | 1887 | 1903 | |||